Authenticity and Appearances: Journeying Past Illusion Into Genuine Practice

It’s only been in the past few years that I’ve divested myself of what I should be as a witch and embraced what I am as a witch. I had struggled to perform in what others saw as my full potential, to the point that I stopped practicing entirely for a period of time while I found my own sense of self again. And when I attuned to that sense again, I looked around at my collection of witchy items and realized that I had become an actor in my own life, with all the props to go along with it. My altar was an installation art piece, every piece technically correct and completely lifeless. My personal practice revolved around deities that I wasn’t in touch with, and probably hadn’t been in touch with for a long time. My outlook on my magickal life was one of endless preparation for cleaning up someone else’s mess. And worst of all, my own thinking about why I practiced was warped by other people’s opinions of what the Craft was, is, should be, could be, and might be.

Unlearning my destiny as a priestess, my duty as a witch, and my devotion to unfamiliar gods led me to a rich garden of finding and learning my own self: my place in the world as a priestex, my true responsibilities to the community, and my deep and abiding love for the divine. Some of the things I learned were surprising to me. Others were truths that I’d denied because they weren’t politically correct.

Witchcraft is not politically correct.

One of the things I learned was that the Gods decide who they are going to interact with. Some of the deities and mythological figures I call upon are from cultures I am far removed from, but I call on them and they answer — some with very specific stipulations about the cost of their attention — not because I sought them out but because they found that I could hear them and do the work they asked of me. I won’t name names because it’s not important. Just know that my policy is that it’s polite to know who you’re working with — their history, their culture, the way they prefer to be addressed, the traditional offerings given to them.

Is it cultural appropriation? I don’t feel like that’s a relevant question. In my personal practice, which is unique to me and my experiences in this life, I venerate certain deities from across the world in a way that is obviously pleasing to them because they haven’t seen fit to tell me otherwise. I don’t think the Gods care much about what culture you come from as long as you’re willing to do the work they need done in the world. It’s a matter of faith, not social science or blood quantum. Am I respectful of the culture of those deities’ origins? Absolutely. And I’m not going to enter into discussions where that culture should be centered unless I’m specifically asked to because at the end of the day, the people who are living with that culture and all that that culture experiences — including colonialization and marginalization — are the ones who need to be heard and listened to. There are places where my spiritual practice is far removed from the real world, and navigating where cultural appreciation ends and cultural appropriation begins is part of being a responsible practitioner and a good ally.

Another thing I’ve learned is that a teacher can lead you to places you don’t want to be in the name of turning you into a well-rounded practitioner, and it’s up to you to correct the course of your own learning. Your learning is about your own life experiences, your own interests, your own unique perspective. Someone — no matter how well-intentioned — who is trying to turn you into something you have no interest in being because you have such great potential or the community needs you does not truly have your interests at heart. Yes, there are things I have learned that I felt unequal to at the time and grew into as I practiced. Yes, there are things I have learned that helped me to do that work to grow. But allowing someone to live vicariously through you is harmful to you and to the other person. I was trained with the assumption that I would be a community leader and a voice in the region and a published author and a coven priestess and an exorcist and a spirit-talker and so many other things — and for a time, I truly believed I could be all of those things at the same time. But when the learning becomes a task that you’re not invested in, that you don’t want to do, that you’re doing only because you’re expected to, that’s when you’re running with the check-engine light on and you need to stop and figure out what’s really calling to you.

I’ve learned that I suck at healing. I have too many chronic conditions that need management and draws away any healing energy I try to raise for another. I’ve learned that I make a really good spirit-talker but not in the way I expected to be. I’ve learned that priestessing a large coven is not for me. I’d rather have a small group where I can devote individual time to the spiritual development of each student and member. I’ve learned that, while I want an educational credential that reflects my expertise as a minister, it’s not necessary to do the work and it’s probably not financially feasible for me because of my career, my health, and my prior financial commitments. It doesn’t stop the wishing, but it does keep me grounded in the material basis of my circumstances.

Another thing I have learned — one might say learned the hard way — is that the religion of my ancestors is a fertile ground from which I can learn more about them and myself. The religion itself and the people who genuinely practice it are not the enemy. It’s some of the institutions that have grown up around it and the political rhetoric that endangers non-practitioners that are the enemy. When I realized that, I came to a number of conclusions about my life, and one of them was that I hadn’t been doing the work my ancestors found important or wanted me to do. After some conference with them, I decided that I was operating under a false dichotomy. I can serve the Gods I’m devoted to and also interact with the ones from my culture. I can preserve the Craft through writing and teaching and also stand up to oppressors who might end up harming or killing me. I can experience the Mysteries and also enjoy the mundane pleasures of life.

Authenticity — being the real me in all its facets — has helped me reject appearances and tap into interests and abilities I hadn’t realized I’d ignored. It’s a practice full of wonder and humor and I look forward to embodying it for the rest of my life.


Discover more from Into the Gloaming with Amy Rhea

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.